MINELRES: ERRC: Bulgarian Court Fines Employer for Denying Access to Employment
Wed Nov 16 19:55:01 2005
Original sender: European Roma Rights Centre <email@example.com>
Trial court finds discrimination by inference and awards Romani victim
compensation in full
Sofia, Budapest, 16 November 2005. With ERRC support, a young Romani man has
won a judgment by the Sofia District court, finding that the refusal of a
private business to hire him constituted direct discrimination based on his
ethnicity. The court has awarded him the full amount of compensation he sought
for non-pecuniary damages - the approximate equivalent in Bulgarian Leva of 300
Euro. The ruling, which is based on the Protection Against Discrimination Act,
Bulgaria's comprehensive antidiscrimination law, is the first to find
discrimination by inference, in accordance with the special rule of the
shifting burden of proof in discrimination cases.
The facts of the case are as follows: In December 2003, the claimant, Mr.
Metody Assenov, age 22, sought to apply for a job as a food production worker
with the respondent, Lubimka Ltd. In response to a job advertisement in the
paper, he placed a telephone call to Lubimka Ltd. to inquire about the terms
and conditions to apply. An employee told him that there was no requirement
other than to be a male younger than 30. She also told him, explicitly, that no
Roma need apply, as no Roma would be hired. In February 2004, the job
advertisement reappeared, and Mr. Assenov called again, making no mention of
his ethnicity. He was invited for an interview. At the interview, the employees
of Lubimka Ltd. treated him less favourably than other job applicants present
by trying to ignore him, and by discouraging him from expecting to be hired. He
had to insist to be interviewed, and to have his details recorded. He was told
the job was too hard, and he was not likely to enjoy it, and that there were
many other applicants. Several weeks later, upon inquiry, he was told that he
had not been hired. He was not offered any explanation of the reason for the
In court, representatives of Lubimka Ltd. argued that their refusal to hire Mr.
Assenov was not race-based, but for a legitimate reason, which was the
claimant's lack of proper qualifications. The court did not consider this
sufficiently established, as there was no evidence that Mr. Assenov had lesser
qualifications than the applicants who had been hired. The court found that
there was enough circumstantial evidence to point to a causal link between Mr.
Assenov's ethnicity and Lubimka Ltd.'s refusal to hire him. In addition, the
court found Lubimka Ltd.'s hiring practices to be non-transparent, lacking
clear, pre-set, duly published criteria. The court held that it was impossible,
therefore, to exclude the conclusion that selection was arbitrary and
discriminatory. The court further ruled that this constituted sufficient
grounds to presume that the claimant was denied a job because of his race, and
to shift the burden of proof to Lubimka Ltd. to rebut the inference of
discrimination. When representatives of Lubimka Ltd. failed to do so, the court
ruled that discrimination had been established in the case. The court's
reasoning includes express language on the principle of the shifting of the
burden of proof in discrimination cases, in line with established case law in
the European Union.
On the occasion of the ruling, ERRC Legal Director Dianne Post said: "The
court's ruling in this case not only brings compensation to a Romani victim; it
also importantly for the first time implements key elements of the EU anti-
discrimination law acquis in Bulgaria."
Counsel for the claimant was the ERRC's Sofia-based consultant on race
discrimination litigation, Margarita Ilieva, in cooperation with local "Romani
Baht" Foundation lawyer Daniela Mihaylova. The judgment is not final.
For further information on the case, please contact ERRC Legal Director Dianne
+36-1-413-2221 (firstname.lastname@example.org), or Margarita Ilieva
at +359-2-943-4876 (email@example.com).
The European Roma Rights Centre is an international public interest law
organisation which monitors the rights of Roma and provides legal defence in
cases of human rights abuse. For more information about the European Roma
Rights Centre, visit the ERRC on the web at http://www.errc.org.
European Roma Rights Centre
1386 Budapest 62
P.O. Box 906/93
Phone: +36 1 4132200
Fax: +36 1 4132201
SUPPORT THE ERRC!
The European Roma Rights Centre is dependent upon the generosity of individual
donors for its continued existence. If you believe the ERRC performs a service
valuable to the public, please join in enabling its future with a contribution.
Gifts of all sizes are welcome; bank transfers are preferred. Please send your
European Roma Rights Centre
Budapest Bank Rt.
Bathory utca 1
For correspondence, to subscribe and unsubscribe from this list, please use:
This message was sent using Endymion MailMan.